• Reports
  • Platform
  • Plans
  • Insights
  • Login
    Start Free Trial
  • Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Social Status

Automate your social media reporting

  • Reports
  • Platform
    • Profile Analytics

      Track and report on the Pages and Profiles you admin

    • Ads Analytics

      Track and report on the Ad Accounts you admin

    • Competitor Analytics

      Track and report on any public competitor Pages and Profiles

    • Influencer Analytics

      Track and report on your Influencer Campaigns

  • Plans
  • Insights
START FREE Login

Articles

Social Media Benchmarks

Social Media Metrics

Best Practice Guides

Does Hootsuite or Buffer cause lower reach and engagement?

By Tim Hill

Thursday July 23 2020

Despite the opinions of many marketers, there’s no recent evidence to support the theory that using 3rd party tools like Hootsuite, Sprout Social or Buffer causes lower reach or engagement.

 

This contentious theory has persisted for nearly 10 years. Whilst there’ve been numerous discussions and studies on this topic we thought we would go to the front line and ask social media marketers themselves. So we surveyed 64 marketers and asked them the all-important question: “Do you believe scheduling posts with Hootsuite, Sprout Social or Buffer negatively impacts your reach or engagement on Facebook or Instagram?”

 

Hootsuite reach survey

 

The result was somewhat predictable, a fairly even split with slightly more marketers believing the theory that Hootsuite and other scheduling tools cause lower reach and engagement.

 

At Social Status we analyze millions of social posts per day across Facebook, Instagram, Twitter, YouTube and LinkedIn. Within our data there was no conclusive evidence to suggest scheduling posts with Hootsuite or a 3rd party tool resulted in lower performance. But this didn’t make sense when compared with the proportion of marketers who believe this theory. So without the support of any recent evidence, we wondered what might be causing this perception in the marketing community. We believe there are two main factors:

 

1. Marketers on the front line are experiencing lower reach and engagement with 3rd party tools

 

I speak to many social marketers through the social media marketing courses I teach at ADMA. Every so often I meet marketers who say they’ve stopped using 3rd party scheduling tools and instead schedule content natively through Facebook’s Creator Studio (for Facebook and Instagram) or Twitter Ads (which supports organic tweet scheduling). YouTube supports video scheduling too. However, LinkedIn is lagging and still doesn’t support native scheduling. These marketers say they experience lower organic reach when scheduling with tools like Hootsuite and Buffer. But when they switch back to native scheduling, they say organic reach improves.

 

2. Vocal thought leaders in the industry are influencing opinion

 

One of the most vocal marketers on this topic is Australian business coach Kerwin Rae. His social accounts have an aggregate following of nearly 2 million people so he has the ability to reach and influence lots of people.

 

Kerwin Rae

 

Back when we all used to attend events in real life (ah, good times), Kerwin frequently filled conference venues and spoke about best practice digital marketing. When talking about social media and this particular topic, he targeted Hootsuite. Kerwin spoke with conviction and warned business owners that scheduling posts with Hootsuite caused noticeable declines in organic reach. He never explained why though. It still led many social marketers to consider Hootsuite alternatives.

 

Where does this leave us?

 

It seems this is a classic case of YMMV. For every marketer that believes this theory, there’s one that doesn’t.

 

YMMV

 

At the end of the day, 3rd party scheduling tools do much more than just scheduling. They are powerful social management platforms that cater for many functional requirements within the social marketing stack. There’s no right or wrong approach when it comes to social media workflow. You and your team need to decide how you want to build your workflow and the processes around it.

 

Before we wrap up, there’s one other aspect to this story that’s worth a mention too:

 

Does Facebook purposely limit the reach of Hootsuite and other scheduling tools?

 

This idea is less about any perceived deficiencies in 3rd party scheduling tools and more about Facebook purposely placing a “cap” on the performance of non-natively scheduled posts. When you look at what Facebook has built with Creator Studio and Facebook Inbox, you can see they are competing hard against Hootsuite, Sprout Social and others across scheduling, community management and moderation functionality. Some in the industry believe Facebook is behind a more malicious intent – to knee-cap these 3rd party tools by artificially limiting the reach of posts scheduled through their platforms thereby enticing their users to Facebook’s own native tools.

 

I really don’t go along with this theory. Again, there’s no evidence to support they’re doing this and it goes against their very business model of more content -> more eyeballs -> more ad dollars at the sake of a landgrab for Hootsuite’s users. It just doesn’t make any sense at all.

 

Aside from this, whatever Facebook do, they ultimately can’t compete with 3rd party scheduling tools. Tools like Hootsuite can schedule content beyond Facebook and Instagram, plus they offer a raft of other features like social listening, social CRM, digital rights management and analytics. All these features plug functional gaps that the social networks themselves are highly unlikely to provide in the foreseeable future.

 

What’s the best way to schedule social posts?

 

Adopt an experimental approach. Try different 3rd party scheduling tools, try native scheduling, try posting live, try as many approaches as you can. If social media has taught us anything as marketers it’s that we should be constantly testing and iterating. The “test and learn” methodology doesn’t just relate to our content but also our workflow. If you feel you could be achieving higher performance, switch things up. Use Profile Analytics to keep a close eye on your Organic Reach Rate (ORR) across all the main social channels:

 

Organic Reach Rate (ORR)

 

For any Hootsuite users frustrated with Hootsuite reports (don’t get us started), you can level-up your reporting game by using Social Status and saving 15% on any of our plans! Check out all the details here: Hootsuite + Social Status.

 

Filed Under: Social Strategy Tagged With: hootsuite, buffer, sprout social

About Tim Hill

Tim Hill is the Co-Founder and CEO at Social Status. Prior to starting Social Status, he spent over 7 years in digital and advertising agencies working with global brands to formulate their social media marketing strategies. Tim also teaches ADMA's (Association for Data-Driven Marketing and Advertising) social media marketing courses in Australia.

Primary Sidebar

  • All Articles
  • Social Strategy
  • News & Trends
  • Product Updates
  • Case Studies

Get Social Status Insights delivered to your inbox once a month:

We respect your privacy.

Follow Social Status on Feedly

Related Articles

8 Facebook Competitor Analysis Tools
Social Strategy

8 Facebook Competitor Analysis Tools for Marketers (2022)

By Tim Hill | December 18 2021

Facebook competitor analysis tools can help any agency or brand to benchmark performance on Facebook and conduct competitor audits quickly and easily.

7 Instagram Competitor Analysis Tools
Social Strategy

7 Instagram Competitor Analysis Tools You Should Know in 2022

By Tim Hill | December 11 2021

Instagram competitor analysis tools can help you benchmark your Instagram performance and understand quickly what kind of content works best.

Social Strategy

8 Social Media Analytics Tips for Small Business

By Tim Hill | June 13 2021

Discover how social media analytics for your small business can help increase your engagement and reach on your social channels. Social analytics are powerful because they make everything you do on social media measurable.

Automate your social media reporting

No credit card required.

Footer Widget Header

G2 2021 Summer Easiest To Do Business With G2 2021 Summer Small Business Easiest To Do Business Wit G2 2021 Summer High Performer G2 2021 Summer Small Business High Performer G2 2021 Spring Users Love Us

Footer

Social Status logo
  • Reports
  • Profile Analytics
  • Ads Analytics
  • Competitor Analytics
  • Influencer Analytics

PRODUCT

  • Reports
  • Platform
  • Profile Analytics
  • Ads Analytics
  • Competitor Analytics
  • Influencer Analytics
  • Plans

COMPANY

  • About
  • Careers
  • Press
  • Support
  • Contact

INSIGHTS

  • All Articles
  • Social Strategy
  • Case Studies
  • News & Trends
  • Product Updates
  • Social Media Best Practice
  • Social Media Benchmarks
  • Social Media Metrics

EXISTING USERS

  • Login

CONNECT WITH US

  • Reports
  • Platform
  • Plans
  • Insights
  • Login
    Start Free Trial
Copyright © 2022. Social Status, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Contact sales +1-415-513-0679
Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Site Map
logo
  • Reports
  • Platform
    • Profile Analytics
    • Ads Analytics
    • Competitor Analytics
    • Influencer Analytics
  • Plans
  • Insights
  • Login
  • Signup